
If you are replacing the water heater at the same time, a Navien tankless unit has the recirculation pump built in, and we configure it for a dedicated return loop or a comfort-style setup depending on your plumbing. Details and the installed price are on our tankless water heater installation page.
Most plumbers consider anything under 15 seconds to be acceptable. In practice, most homeowners without recirculation in a larger home are waiting 45 seconds to over a minute. The wait depends on how far your fixture is from the water heater, the diameter of the pipe feeding it, and how long the system has been idle. A 3/4-inch supply line running 60 feet holds roughly 1.5 gallons of cooled-off water, and at a standard faucet flow rate that takes about a minute to clear. A recirculation pump reduces that wait to seconds.
A dedicated return loop runs a separate pipe from the farthest fixture back to the water heater, creating a closed loop that the pump keeps circulating at full temperature. A comfort system instead uses the existing cold water line as the return path, which makes it practical for homes that were not plumbed with a return line. The tradeoff is temperature: comfort systems cap delivery at around 95 to 100 degrees rather than full hot, and the wait time is much improved versus not having a pump at all.
Yes, with a few considerations. Many high-efficiency tankless units, including Navien models, include an integrated recirculation pump that is designed to work with the unit's flow detection. Using a standalone recirculation pump with a tankless water heater requires some care in setup because tankless units only fire when they detect a minimum flow rate. A comfort system with a properly set timer or demand control avoids triggering the burner unnecessarily. We assess your specific tankless unit and home layout before recommending a recirculation approach.
A properly configured comfort system includes a temperature-limiting sensor valve that shuts the pump off once the cold water line reaches around 95 to 100 degrees. This prevents the cold line from getting uncomfortably warm. If your comfort system is making the cold water noticeably warm, the sensor valve may be set incorrectly or has failed, and it should be inspected. A well-functioning comfort system should deliver noticeably cooler water from the cold tap than from the hot.
A recirculation pump running continuously does use energy and does cause your water heater to fire more frequently to maintain line temperature. However, most of that cost can be minimized with a programmable timer or an on-demand controller. A timer-based setup runs the pump only during the hours your household is active, which eliminates most of the standby losses. On-demand systems activate the pump only when triggered by a button or motion sensor, which is the most efficient approach. When Zest Plumbing & Drain installs a recirculation system, we help you configure the controls to match your household's schedule.
A comfort system can be installed in almost any home without structural modifications, since it uses the existing cold water line as the return path. The installation typically involves connecting the pump at the water heater and placing a sensor valve at the farthest fixture. A dedicated return loop requires a return line to be run from the farthest fixture back to the water heater, which is more involved in a finished home but can easily be part of new construction and remodel projects. We assess your home's layout and give you an honest recommendation on which system fits your situation and budget.
The most obvious sign is that your hot water wait time has returned to what it was before the pump was installed. You may also hear the pump running continuously when it should be cycling on and off, or not running at all during active hours. Pump noise, vibration at the water heater, or warm water coming from the cold tap can also indicate a sensor valve issue. Recirculation pumps in Arizona homes are also prone to scale buildup from hard water, which can restrict flow over time. If you notice any of these symptoms, a service call will usually identify the issue quickly.